Close Menu
November 15, 2026 • 8:16 AM
Opinion

Ambassador, Before Presenting Cambodia's Story, Please Share the Full Truth About the Refugee Camps

November 15, 2026
Ambassador, Before Presenting Cambodia's Story, Please Share the Full Truth About the Refugee Camps

An open reply to Thai Ambassador Cherdchai Chaivaivid at the United Nations General Assembly

Dear Ambassador Cherdchai Chaivaivid,

On September 28, you told the UN General Assembly that Cambodians still living in areas first set up as temporary shelters in the 1970s have refused to go home, and that their presence amounts to an encroachment on Thai soil. The international community deserves more than one version of these events. It deserves the facts, the historical context, and the voices of those who lived through them.

A crisis born of war, not choice

Cambodia's refugee crisis did not arise because Cambodians decided to occupy someone else's land. It grew out of war, political violence, displacement, and insecurity after the fall of the Khmer Rouge regime in 1979.

Thousands of Cambodian civilians fled toward the Thai border seeking safety. The crisis reached such a scale that it became an international humanitarian emergency, drawing in UN agencies, the International Committee of the Red Cross, and many international and local organizations.

US government records, for example, note that First Lady Rosalynn Carter visited Thailand in November 1979 and saw the conditions faced by Cambodian and other Indochinese refugees, including children with malaria and malnutrition.

That history matters. The camps did not simply appear without cause.

Thailand's role deserves honest examination

Thailand offered refuge and humanitarian aid, and that contribution deserves recognition. But recognizing it does not mean every action by Thai authorities during the refugee years should go unscrutinized.

In 1979, US diplomatic records and congressional documents described the forced return of Cambodian refugees and the dangers facing people pushed back into areas containing mines and other hazards. Thailand later changed its policy on accepting Cambodian refugees for temporary asylum.

The historical record therefore holds both humanitarian assistance and serious controversies over the protection of refugees. If Thailand wants the international community to look at the past, it should be willing to examine the entire record, including the uncomfortable parts.

The camps were also pawns in the Cold War

Another essential piece of the story is the geopolitical struggle surrounding Cambodia during the 1980s.

Cambodia became caught in a regional conflict involving Vietnam, China, the Soviet Union, Thailand, the United States, and competing Cambodian political and military factions. The camps and settlements along the Thai border consequently took on significance beyond their humanitarian purpose.

Former UN High Commissioner for Refugees Sadako Ogata described how geopolitical considerations shaped the treatment of Indochinese refugees and how some international actors backed Cambodian resistance factions along the Thai border as a counterweight to the Vietnamese-backed government in Phnom Penh.

This does not mean refugees should be cast as combatants, nor did every camp serve the same purpose. It does mean the history cannot be understood through the humanitarian label of "temporary shelter" alone. Security concerns, political interests, and humanitarian needs existed side by side, while ordinary Cambodian families often had little control over the forces shaping their lives.

That context is essential when discussing how and why Cambodian communities came to live along the border.

Were the camps truly temporary?

The word "temporary" also needs context.

Some Cambodian refugees stayed in camps for years. Khao-I-Dang, established in 1979, eventually sheltered nearly 140,000 refugees at its peak and remained open until 1993. Along the border, displaced populations faced insecurity, evacuations, and shifting conditions as the conflict dragged on.

For families who had lost homes, land, and possessions, a camp could be the only place where they believed they could survive. The fact that a settlement was meant to be temporary does not, by itself, prove that everyone there could safely return immediately.

But this point must be applied carefully. The existence of refugee camps decades ago does not automatically determine the legal status of people living in a particular border location today. That question requires present-day evidence.

The refugees did return

The 1991 Paris Peace Agreements fundamentally changed Cambodia's political circumstances.

Beginning in March 1992, UNHCR supported the return of roughly 370,000 Cambodian refugees from the Thai border to areas of their choice inside Cambodia, in time to take part in UN-supervised elections.

Their return shows why the refugee story cannot be reduced to an accusation that people "failed to go home." Repatriation required a political settlement, international coordination, transportation, reintegration assistance, and conditions in which people could rebuild their lives. The crisis was ultimately resolved through an international peace process, not through a simple demand that displaced people leave.

If Thailand has a territorial claim, let the evidence be heard

Ambassador, Thailand has a legitimate interest in protecting its territorial integrity, and Cambodia has the same right.

But a territorial dispute cannot be settled fairly through historical rhetoric alone. If Thailand believes that particular Cambodian families or communities are living on Thai territory, it should identify the precise locations and present the relevant evidence: applicable boundary instruments, maps, historical records, the circumstances in which settlements were established, and evidence concerning the present population. Cambodia should likewise present its own legal position and evidence.

Neither the history of refugee camps nor the passage of time automatically determines sovereignty. Equally, that history should not be erased when examining how people came to live in a particular area.

Where a genuine boundary dispute exists, the parties should use appropriate bilateral mechanisms and peaceful procedures under international law. Where civilians face humanitarian difficulties, their safety and dignity should remain a priority. The international community should be able to examine the evidence impartially rather than being asked to accept either government's narrative without scrutiny.

Cambodia's history deserves to be heard

Ambassador Cherdchai, you spoke to the international community from the UN General Assembly podium, and that carries real responsibility. The UN is not simply a place where governments defend national positions. It is also an institution through which the world remembers humanitarian tragedies, examines evidence, and seeks peaceful solutions to disputes.

Cambodians remember the years when their country was devastated, when families fled toward the border, when international organizations set up relief operations, and when the fate of refugees became entangled in Cold War politics. That history cannot be reduced to a statement that people did not return home.

I am not asking Thailand to abandon its position. I am asking it to acknowledge the complete history and allow the evidence to be examined fairly.

If Thailand wishes to discuss the presence of Cambodians in former refugee areas, it should also explain the circumstances that created those areas, the role of international humanitarian organizations, the political and military realities of the Cold War, and the subsequent international effort to return displaced people to Cambodia.

If the question is territorial sovereignty today, let the relevant legal instruments, maps, and evidence be examined through peaceful and appropriate procedures. If the question concerns the welfare of civilians living near the border, let their safety and dignity come first.

The people who lived through these events deserve more than slogans. So does the truth.

← Sakor Watch