Beneath the Border Clashes: Why Cambodia and Thailand's Tensions Keep Returning

Once the treaties are signed and the guns fall silent, a frontier may appear calm again. But what happens when the root causes of the conflict were never addressed?
The 2008–2011 confrontation between Cambodia and Thailand raises a key question: how much did the issues left unresolved after that conflict shape the fighting of 2025?
This article contends that the earlier conflict helped create the conditions that made renewed clashes possible. It examines three areas: broader territorial disagreements that were never settled, the politicisation of cultural heritage, and the shortcomings of international institutions. These factors do not fully explain the renewed fighting, but their persistence helps explain why relations between the two countries remain so difficult to repair.
Historical Background
The roots of both the 2008–2011 conflict and the fighting of 2025 can be traced to the colonial era. Colonial-period maps placed Preah Vihear within Cambodian territory, a position the International Court of Justice (ICJ) upheld in 1962 and clarified in 2013, although wider border disputes remained open. After UNESCO inscribed the Preah Vihear Temple on its World Heritage List in 2008, nationalist feeling fuelled a series of armed clashes between Cambodia and Thailand that lasted until 2011.
The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) tried to intervene, but its influence was limited by its principle of non-interference and by its difficulty in reaching consensus among members. It did, however, help facilitate negotiations between the two countries.
At around the same time, Cambodia formally asked the ICJ for a clarifying interpretation of its 1962 judgment. The court had affirmed Cambodian sovereignty over the entire promontory on which the temple stands. Even so, this did not produce a comprehensive settlement of the disagreements between the two countries.
Relations were relatively cooperative in the years following the 2008–2011 conflict, although tensions over the disputed territory persisted. The death of a Cambodian soldier in 2025 reignited hostilities, and both sides mobilised their militaries in response.
What followed was a pattern of intermittent fighting along the frontier that came to define the conflict. The clashes caused deaths among soldiers and civilians, displaced local residents and destroyed property.
The international community, led by ASEAN, the United States and China, tried to mediate and secured a temporary ceasefire in October, but no conclusive resolution followed. After fighting broke out again in December, Cambodia and Thailand agreed to another ceasefire on December 27, 2025. The deal allowed international mediators and bilateral cooperation envoys to observe the disputed territories, and that observation is still ongoing.
So what does the 2025 conflict reveal about the hostilities of 2008–2011?
Unresolved Territorial Disputes
Settling the question of the temple's sovereignty, through the 1962 ICJ case and its 2013 clarification, did not resolve the wider territorial tensions between Cambodia and Thailand.
The 1962 case concerned only the temple's sovereignty and the withdrawal of Thai forces from the temple and its vicinity on Cambodian territory. In 2013, the ICJ clarified that its ruling covered the entire Preah Vihear promontory, but it did not determine how the full Cambodia–Thailand border should be demarcated. Applying the principle of ‘non ultra petita’, the court issued its decision based solely on Cambodia's specific request.
The May 2025 fighting near the Emerald Triangle, where Cambodia, Laos and Thailand meet, along with the July and December clashes around the Tamone and Ta Krabei temples, showed that territorial disputes persisted in other parts of the border region.
If territorial disagreements remain unsettled, they will continue to complicate relations between the two countries. Until both sides agree on a clear and precise border, these disputes are likely to shape their diplomatic ties for decades.
Taking the matter to the international court seems unlikely, because neither country is willing to cede territory to the other. Each side fears that appearing to give ground would stir nationalist sentiment and provoke unrest at home.
The Thai government's support for the Preah Vihear inscription illustrates this. It faced heavy backlash from Thai nationalists, who saw the listing as a concession of the temple and the surrounding land to Cambodia.
The political cost of accepting an unfavourable outcome may therefore discourage leaders from pursuing or implementing a final settlement.
Cultural Heritage and Historical Memory as Tools of Nationalism
The disputes over Preah Vihear and other temples also show how cultural heritage has been used to justify nationalism and reinforce territorial claims.
When UNESCO added Preah Vihear to the World Heritage List in 2008, the listing included Cambodia's name beside the temple, explicitly stating that the site belonged to Cambodia alone. This turned the temple into a focal point of an existing territorial dispute.
In 2025, Ta Krabei, Tamone and Preah Vihear again became flashpoints. In February, groups of tourists reportedly visited these temples singing nationalist songs to assert Cambodian ownership, which angered Thai citizens.
These temples form part of the shared history of the Khmer Empire, and their cultural and historical meaning extends well beyond the lines drawn on a map. However, when people tie monuments such as Preah Vihear to their national identity, giving up any part of them can be seen as surrendering a piece of their heritage.
Political actors can exploit these feelings by presenting the defence of a temple as a patriotic duty and any compromise as a betrayal of the nation's heritage. Because the territorial tensions from the 2008 conflict were never resolved, similar narratives were mobilised again in 2025.
In this way, the earlier conflict reinforced the politicisation of cultural heritage in later disputes. It further entangled the dispute with national identity and made it harder to resolve.
The Limits of ASEAN in Resolving Regional Disputes
ASEAN is the region's principal international body and plays an important role in facilitating peaceful, diplomatic solutions among its member states. However, under its charter it serves only in an advisory capacity, so it can engage only through indirect diplomacy, offering suggestions to the parties involved.
As a consequence, ASEAN's efforts have not always been sufficient to address a multifaceted conflict such as the one between Cambodia and Thailand.
During the 2008–2011 conflict, ASEAN sought to de-escalate the situation by urging both countries to agree to an immediate ceasefire.
Nevertheless, Thailand's preference for resolving the dispute through bilateral negotiations limited ASEAN's effectiveness. The bloc adhered to the non-interference principle at the centre of its charter, which constrained how far it could go.