Referee Under Fire After Army Red Card Row as Crown Suffer First Loss

A disputed red card for Royal Cambodian Armed Forces (RCAF) goalkeeper Mat Lany has put referee Sary Thanak under heavy scrutiny. The decision came during a Cambodian Premier League match against Life FC at Old Stadium on Sunday, and it ended with Army head coach Phea Sopheatra also being sent off for protesting. Elsewhere that day, Phnom Penh Crown lost their first league game of the season.
A Contested Dismissal
Many spectators felt Lany had already won the ball when he pushed away an onrushing Life FC player with his left hand. The contact looked minor, yet the visitor went down theatrically and stayed on the turf, prompting calls for a card. Few fans expected the punishment that followed. After conferring with his assistant, Thanak sent Lany off and awarded Life FC a penalty.
Army's officials, coaching staff and players protested loudly, but the referee stood his ground. He then showed a second red card to Phea Sopheatra for his objections. Play was held up for more than five minutes while the argument continued.
A Match Turned on Its Head
Bruno converted the penalty in first-half stoppage time, and Life FC went on to score three more goals against a Army side down to ten men. Kanta Asami scored in the 52nd and 58th minutes, and Bruno added a second goal in the 76th to seal a comfortable win.
Reaction From the Sidelines
Army general manager Thong Udom shared a short clip of the incident, which occurred in the 42nd minute, on social media. He added a pointed message aimed at the referee: “Make up your own mind, Mr Red Shirt. When we protested, you said the opponent had a chance to challenge for the ball.” The remark targeted Thanak's explanation that the Life FC player still had a chance to compete for possession. Army maintains that Lany had already controlled the ball in his hands.
Veteran coach Prak Sovannara, who has managed several CPL clubs including Life FC, also called the decision questionable and accused the opposing player of play-acting. He asked why the match commissioner had not used television replays to help the referee review the incident before the card was shown. “Now that we have television coverage, can the match commissioner help review the footage and provide information to the referee? If things continue like this, our standard remains very low,” he said on social media. He added that a push of such little force would not knock over even a 60-year-old.
Refereeing has long been a sore point in the league. Many supporters argue that while clubs have improved, officiating has failed to keep pace. Still, referees operate under intense pressure, and controversial calls are not always deliberate. Officials often end up criticised by both sides whenever a contentious moment arises.
Crown's First Defeat of the Season
Phnom Penh Crown's loss came only days after they beat Hong Kong's Kitchee SC 2-0 in the group stage of the 2026-27 AFC Champions League Two on October 29. Against MOI Kampong Dava, they went down 1-0, with Kim Hyeonsu's header in the 55th minute deciding the match. The defeat ended their unbeaten domestic run and leaves them seventh in the standings with seven points. Visakha top the table on 16 points, followed by NagaWorld on 14.